Illustration of a menu featuring food items for different meal times including donuts and coffee for breakfast, pizza and subs for lunch, and ice cream for dessert, with hand-drawn style images of each item.

Welcome to my Freakin Pizza & Sweets!

Once known as 2 companies, Freakin Sweets & My Freakin Pizza, is now under one brand and one roof for a donut-pizza-ice cream Sweetzaria collision your taste buds and family will love. Check out our Award for BEST gluten free pizza in St. Joseph County AND our award for Best Donut, our Canadian donut.

A cartoon slice of pepperoni pizza with a smiling face, arms, and fingers, making an 'L' sign with one hand, and holding a banner that says 'My Freakin Pizza & Sweets' with a purple background.
A happy family of five standing indoors, with a young girl holding a bouquet of flowers in the center. The family includes a man, woman, and three young girls, all smiling and posing for the photo.

We're the Merrill family, and we're thrilled to welcome you to our passion project: the perfect combination of our beloved Freakin Sweets and the newly revamped Mike's Pizza, now under one delicious roof!

Our story is simple: we love food, we love our community, and we wanted to create a place where families like ours could enjoy quality meals and treats throughout the day. From breakfast to dinner, and of course, something sweet to finish—we've got you covered!

What makes us different? We stay true to traditions that matter. Our stone-baked, hand-tossed pizzas follow a cherished 43-year-old recipe that our community has loved for generations. Every ingredient is selected with care because we believe you can taste the difference quality makes.

On the sweeter side, we bring imagination to life with our creative confections. Each treat is handcrafted with the same attention to detail we give to everything we serve.

And because we know what it's like dining out with little ones, we've created a special area just for kids—a space where they can be themselves while you enjoy a moment of peace (and pizza!).

So whether you're stopping by for a quick breakfast, family dinner, or satisfying your sweet tooth, we're here to serve you the best of both worlds. Come taste what happens when passion meets tradition at My Freakin Pizza and Sweets!

— The Merrill Family

A partially eaten blueberry donut on a paper plate, with a blurred background showing a neon sign spelling 'donuts' and a display case with donuts.

Donuts

Made to Order

  • Here you’ll see no giant case with donuts that have sat around all day. In fact, every donut is MADE TO ORDER. Stop in at our counter, choose your donut flavors and let our team make them fresh for you!

    In a time crunch? Feel free to call ahead 269-464-4030, tell us which donuts you’d like, and they’ll be ready for you to walk in and grab.

  • Donuts are available EVERY day we’re open, all day long. Monday - Sunday (closed Tuesdays)

    Early hours? Friday - Sundays we open earlier than normal just for extra early donut hours.

    Monday 11am-8pm

    Tuesday CLOSED

    Wednesday & Thursday 11am-8pm

    Friday & Saturday 7am-9pm

    Sunday 8am-8pm

    We also Deliver with Doordash!

Deep-dish pizza with pickles and drizzled mayonnaise, with a bottle of Mike's Hot Honey in the background.

Pizza

Homemade - Hand Tossed - Stone Baked

  • My Freakin Pizza revives the Original Mike’s Pizza’s 43 year old homemade recipe with new ownership in combination with Freakin Sweets, a Sturgis specialty Donut and Ice Cream shoppe since 2022.

    LEARN MORE

  • Order through our website where we assign a delivery driver via Doordash or Uber Eats, OR you can call it in and pick up on your time! We’re also available on Doordash. Open every day except Tuesdays at 11am for lunch.

    Parking available up front or in the back, take the alley to the left of Wings Etc.

Two milkshakes topped with donuts and whipped cream, with strawberry syrup and toppings in a fast food setting.

Ice Cream

Michigan Made (Shermans, Ashbys, MI Fresh)

  • All of our Ice Cream is made in Michigan! Currently we have Shermans out of South Haven, Ashbys and Michigan Fresh. We hold 20 flavors at all times, including one NSA, a Dairy Free flavor, and 2 Lactose Free flavors.

    Want a waffle cone? We make them fresh daily! We have Vanilla and old timey Chocolate, a historic ice cream shoppe classic.

    Looking for shakes? Try our Top Shake flavors, create your own concoction or turn it into a Freak Shake! Made with our hand dipped ice cream and topped with one of our specialty donuts.

    Check out our full menu HERE

  • Ice Cream Delivered? ABSOLUTELY! Get some of our menu items through our website or visit Doordash directly.

    Want to walk in and enjoy your ice cream with a stroll downtown? We’d love to have you stop in.

    Short on time? Give us a call and we can have it ready for pick-up.

“Life is too short to skip dessert, so count memories not calories”

-so said the smartest person ever, whoever that may be